Challenging Job Interview Questions: 4 Simple Tips You Need To Know

Have you ever been to a conference or networking event where you spend the entire time conversing with colleagues, but leave feeling alone — like you actually haven’t connected with anyone? For hiring managers, this is what a day of asking job interview questions often feels like.

When people feel they need to put their best foot forward, they often stick to scripts about expected topics. The problem with presenting yourself this way is that it’s often inauthentic, and let’s be honest, not very memorable. If everyone is sticking to the same script it’s hard to stand out from the crowd.

What can make a difference in answering job interview questions? Letting go of your over-polished self just enough to tell a story that illustrates your character. When people drop the scripts and talk about something slightly unexpected, it feels like a refreshing breeze in a stuffy room.

Stories make a difference in job interviews. Here are four tips for using storytelling during the interview process.

How To Ace The Hardest Job Interview Questions

1. Don’t overshare.

Choose a story from the realm of “personal” but not “private.” Experienced teachers are often masters of this — establishing rapport with their students by divulging some personal details (a food they abhor, a favorite song or movie, a fun holiday memory). But they avoid private details that students have no need to know. You can walk that same line in a job interview.

Find the right level of vulnerability. A challenging job interview question that often comes up is “Tell me about a failure?” or “What are your strengths and weaknesses?” These are great opportunities to tell a leadership story that shows your character. The key is to choose wisely and then tell it with confidence. A survey of hiring managers by Resume.org, published in May 2025, 39% cases where a Gen Z employee wasn’t a right fit for the company cited a lack of professionalism as a leading cause. Some of the specific ways that manifested was tardiness and not responding well to feedback. Being able to show both professionalism and vulnerability will set you apart from other candidates of any age. If you choose to tell a failure story, be sure that suggests that you lacked experience but not character. 

2. Don’t ramble.

Keep it under three minutes max. Telling a story doesn’t need to take very long. It’s not about sharing all the facts, it’s about sharing the right details. In three minutes you can structure an impactful story, using the IRS method. That’s enough for a 30-second beginning, a minute and a half to develop your story, and a minute to bring it to a close with reflections on why it’s relevant. Let my IRS model be your mantra as you structure stories for your interview:

• I – Intriguing Beginning: In the first 30 seconds, set up an intriguing problem.
• R – Riveting Middle: In the next 1.5 minutes, develop your story, maintaining the tension. The key here is editing out unnecessary details.
• S – Satisfying End: In the last minute, bring your story to a close with reflections on why it’s relevant.

The most important part is the intriguing beginning. In the first few seconds, the the story should capture your interviewer’s imagination or you may lose their attention.

3. Don’t limit yourself to the role of “hero.”

When you’re trying to land a new job, it’s easy to think you should be the hero of every story so that the hiring team can see all the skills you bring to the role. But you have other options. Interesting stories that demonstrate your character can arise from your role as friend, mentor, sidekick, or witness to a discovery or a beautiful transformation. Keep in mind that a Pew Research Center survey in 2024 found that 64% of people who were satisfied with their jobs cited good relationships with their coworkers as one of the primary reasons why. It is often wise to show that you’re a team player who values strong relationships with coworkers.

4. Don’t forget the takeaway.

Frame your story so it leads to a takeaway. What do you want the exhausted interviewer, who may have seen 12 other candidates before you, to remember? If they remember nothing else, what do you hope they take away? Build on this to create an unforgettable ending. Make sure the takeaway directly answers the job interview question.

Storytelling Example: How To Answer “Failure” Job Interview Questions

Here’s an example of a brief but impactful story that shows the storyteller’s character and growth. This is a great way to answer the inevitable job interview questions about failure or weaknesses. Pay attention to the Intriguing beginning, Riveting middle and Satisfying end:

“I was in a new role leading a team to develop a new app. My superior came to me and told me the deadline was moved up by six months, so we could market it alongside the release of a related product. I knew it was a bad idea. But I was new to the company, so I just said, ‘Okay.’

My gut was right. My team worked the best they could, but the complexities and the design of the app were not given the time and thoughtfulness they truly required. When the app was released, my fears were confirmed. It was a total flop and only received bad reviews.

From that experience, I’ve learned to always speak up — even if it makes me uncomfortable. The next time, my manager came to me with news that set off red flags, instead of agreeing, I asked questions. I worked with him to understand the larger situation and find a solution that was better for the company’s overall mission, rather than focus on short-term goals.”

This story is successful because it’s relatable and shows how he put what he learned into practice immediately.

The Most Important Part Of A Memorable Job Interview

Remember, interviewers are human too. Yes, they hold a certain power over you, but just like you, they want genuine connection. Look straight into their eyes and smile. Don’t touch your phone during the interview itself. Sit up straight and show with your body language that you’re fully engaged in talking to the interviewer.

Interviewers need to understand who you are as a potential future colleague in the organization. If the interviewer is talking, ask followup questions and show your listening skills. Treating the person across from you with respect, in addition to offering smart answers with specific details when they ask questions, can go a long way. Applying all these tips will make answering even the most challenging job interview questions less challenging and more enjoyable, for everyone.

Related Articles

3 Practical Guidelines For Writing A Better LinkedIn ‘About’ Section

What You Need To Know For Your Annual Performance Review